Search Console

“Alternate page with proper canonical tag”, in plain words

The address is another version of a page Google already shows, and it says so correctly. Google’s own help says there is nothing you need to do. It is worth one look only when the page Google shows instead is the wrong one.

Checked 17 November 2026 · Mathis

Usually there is nothing to fix

This page points to another page as the main version, with a canonical tag, and Google shows that main version in search. That is the tag doing its job. Check it only if a page you want found is in this list on its own, or if the list suddenly grows after a change to your site.

  • The page Google shows instead is already in search
  • A canonical tag names the main version of a page
  • Worth a check when every page points to the same address

What Google is telling you

When the same page can be reached at several addresses, the canonical is the one you want shown in search. A canonical tag is a line in the page’s code that names it. Most site builders and shop platforms write it for you.

<link rel="canonical" href="https://yourshop.com/red-shoes">

This reason means the address carries such a tag, it points to another page, and that other page is indexed: it is on the list Google can show in search. Google’s help puts it plainly: the page points to the canonical page correctly, so there is nothing you need to do.

Google treats a canonical tag as a strong hint, not a rule. When Google disagrees with your tag, the reason is a different one, “Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user”.

Where you see it in Search Console

  1. 1

    Open the page indexing report

    In Search Console, choose your site, then Indexing, then Pages.

  2. 2

    Find the reason

    Scroll to “Why pages aren’t indexed” and click “Alternate page with proper canonical tag”.

  3. 3

    Check where one points

    Paste an address in the search bar at the top of Search Console. Under Page indexing, “User-declared canonical” is the page you named and “Google-selected canonical” is the one Google shows.

When it matters, and when it does not

A long list here is normal, and it is often a sign that your canonical tags work. Three cases deserve a look:

  • A page you want found on its own is here. A page made for one kind of customer that points to your general page will not be shown for its own searches
  • Most of your pages point to the same address, often the home page. That is a template that writes one canonical for every page, and only that one page can be shown
  • The count jumped after you changed theme, platform or site builder

Addresses you will usually find here

Any address whose canonical points to another indexed page can show up here. On a small site these are the usual ones:

  • Links with tracking codes, such as ?utm_source=newsletter or ?ref=partner
  • Sorted or filtered versions of a list, such as ?sort=price
  • A product a shop shows under several categories, each with its own address
  • A mobile or AMP copy of a page, the case Google’s help names first

Language versions are not part of it: Google’s help says Search Console does not detect alternate language pages under this reason.

What to check, and what to change

  1. 1

    Open a few addresses from the list

    If each one is a variant of a page that is in search, stop here. Nothing needs doing.

  2. 2

    Fix a canonical that points to the wrong page

    Each page that should be found on its own should name itself as canonical. Google recommends that self-pointing tag. Change it in the page’s settings, your SEO plugin or the template, depending on where your site builder writes it.

  3. 3

    Make sure the page is not a near copy

    If a page made for designers says the same as your general page with one word changed, Google may still treat it as a copy. Give it what that customer needs to decide.

  4. 4

    Link to the main address

    In your menu, your own links and your sitemap, use the address you named as canonical. Google says linking to it consistently helps it follow your choice.

  5. 5

    Ask once

    For a page you changed, paste its address in the search bar, then click “Request indexing”.

How PlainSEO reads it for your site

PlainSEO reads your Search Console and lists the pages closest to more buyers. A page that sells but names another page as canonical cannot be on that list, because Google shows the other one. If a page you expected is missing there, check its canonical first. On a paid plan, the Monday check reads the pages that matter live and tells you when one names another page as its canonical.

If Google shows a page but few people click it, the click rate guide is the next thing to read.

Mathis, who makes PlainSEO

Mathis

Checked 17 November 2026

Makes PlainSEO. Writes these guides from what he sees in owners’ Search Console data.

Questions

Should I fix “Alternate page with proper canonical tag”?

Usually not. Google lists these addresses because they point correctly to a page it already shows. Fix only a page that should be found on its own, or a template that points every page to one address.

What is a canonical URL?

The address you want shown in search when one page can be reached at several. You name it with a canonical tag in the page’s code, and Google takes it as a strong hint.

Does it hurt my site to have many pages here?

No. Duplicate and alternate versions should not be in search, and Google’s help calls this usually a good thing: it found the main page and indexed it.

How is it different from “Duplicate without user-selected canonical”?

Here the page names its main version itself. In the other, the page names none and Google picked one. The guide to that reason covers it.

See what this means for your own site

Free, no card. Type your address to start: the pages closest to more buyers are ready a few minutes after you connect Search Console.

Questions, or want help reading your results? Write to me.